Hi Roger,
Me thinks your statements are a tad too black & white.
My Rotax 9 experience is limited to about 10 years on my last aircraft an ATEC Zephyr/912ULS, Fiti, 2 blade, ground adjustable, prop.
I set the STATIC to a smidgeon under 5200RPM / WOT. This gave the aircraft (full fuel 87L, 1 pax) a 100m ground role, on grass and a 1000+ft/min Climb Out (care taken to stay within the Rotax Max RPM/5 minutes). Cruise at 100 knots, 5200RPM. 12.5L/hr Conservative fuel planning 14L/hr covered all weight, air speed eventualities. On rare occasions I would do a beach run at 500ft AMSL @ 120 knots, 5500 rpm.
I know the aircraft was capable of 125 knots but this would have required a STATIC of probably under 5000RPM/WOT. So I estimate I may have lost about 5 knots at an air speed I would not have used very often, if at all.
Fuel consumption was outstanding and I never added oil between services.
Engine temperatures were such, that a large temporary "cowl flap" was employed for winter conditions (under 25C)
Note: Air speeds are all as indicated ie subject to instrument error. Fuel consumption/sortie, calculated using graduated cylinder.