Okay so you are talking CHT.& EGT
1. In the standard Rotax 9 configuration you only have two CHT's. Usually on #2 & #3. Do you have additional CHT on #1 & #4?
2. Unless your Rotax is a very early model, the CHT is cylinder coolant temperature.
3. Coolant temperatures of 186F(85.5C) is well within the normal operating range of up to redline/danger of 120C.
4. Oil temperature of 158F (70C) is a bit on the low side for cruise.
5. It is not unusual to see small differences in EGT probe readings caused by differences in cooling air flow, slight air:fuel mixture differences, etc.
6. I have no experience with pusher configurations however in tractor, we usually only monitor the rear two (# 3 & #4) cylinder EGT's because these are most likely to be the hotter, due to operating in the prewarmed air from #1 & #2. Cylinder/exhaust manifolds #1 & # 2 are likely to have cooler temps, particularly#1 as it is slightly further forward than # 2. The confused airflow in a pusher/gyro set up may further confuse EGT readings.
6. "White" plugs is a sigh of too lean a mixture/engine running hot - you will need to increase fuel : air ratio.
7. Airflow can effect mixture. Constricted airflow (eg blocked air filter(s) will cause the engine to run rich (dark/black plugs). A hole in a inlet manifold to head gasket may cause that cylinder to receive additional air and run lean. Leaning the mixture will cause the engine (cylinder) to run hot (light/white plugs).
Speculation: If only one cylinder is running significantly hotter than the rest, this may be something to do with a leaking inlet gasket/manifold at that cylinder.