Hi Jeff,
"Carburetors drawing air from inside the cowl would be similar to running carb heat all the time"
I agree however its not all bad - my last 912ULS didn't have carburettor heat, in the 11 years I had the aircraft, never a hint of ice. Undercowl temps routinely 10C above ambient.
My new 912ULS, has a home produced airbox, delivering outside air (has water heated anti ice) Diffrent aircraft/propeller so hard to make performance comparison.